Paul D. Coverdell World Wise Schools - Culture Matters

Concept of Power:
High and Low Power Distance

In this exercise, you consider the notion of power distance. This concept is larger than the workplace, having as its focus the attitude of a society toward inequality -how cultures deal with difference in access people have to power and their level of status - but it is manifest especially in workplace relations, particularly in the role and relationship of the manager and the subordinate. The following brief descriptions of the two poles of this concept--high and low power distance--suggest the issues involved:


Photo of woman pumping water in Ghana.
HIGH POWER DISTANCE: Cultures where high power distance typifies the workplace accept that inequalities in power and status are natural or existential. In the same way they accept that some people are smarter than others, people accept that some will have more power and influence than others. Those with power tend to emphasize it, to hold it close and not delegate or share it, and to distinguish themselves as much as possible from those who do not have power. They are, however, expected to accept the responsibilities that go with power, to look after those beneath them. Subordinates are not expected to take initiative and are closely supervised.

LOW POWER DISTANCE: People in these cultures see inequalities in power and status as largely artificial; it is not natural, though it may be convenient, that some people have power over others. Those with power, therefore, tend to deemphasize it, to minimize the differences between themselves and subordinates, and to delegate and share power to the extent possible. Subordinates are rewarded for taking initiative and do not like close supervision.

In the space before each of the statements below, put an "H" if you think it reflects an attitude of high power distance, or an "L" if low power distance is more likely:

  1. People are less likely to question the boss.
  2. Elitism is the norm.
  3. Students question teachers.
  4. Freedom of thought is encouraged.
  5. Those in power have special privileges.
  6. The chain of command is mainly for convenience.
  7. There are greater wage differences between managers and subordinates.
  8. Workers prefer precise instructions from superiors.
  9. Interaction between boss and subordinate is more informal.
  10. Subordinates and bosses are independent.
  11. Bosses are independent; subordinates are dependent.
  12. Freedom of thought could get you in trouble.
  13. It's OK to question the boss.
  14. Less social mobility is the norm.
  15. The chain of command is sacred.
  16. The pecking order is clearly established.
  17. Management style is authoritarian and paternalistic.
  18. Management style is consultative and democratic.
  19. Interaction between boss and subordinate is formal.

Back to From Jan's Journal Next Page

 

 

 

 

Culture Matters
 

Culture Matters Home Page

Chapter Four Contents

Using Culture Matters

Chapter Summaries

Help

   

Peace Corps

Receive Updates and News